Message to Man 2012 Winners

The St. Petersburg festival ended with several awards as the tradition goes at the festival that covers documentaries, long and short, animation, short fiction and experimental films. Headed by Austrian director Michael Glawogger the international jury gave the main prize, the Golden Centaur, to the 15 minutes long Slovakian film ”The Last Bus” by Martin Snopek, a mix in style between animation and live action. Best long documentary award was given to the beautiful Italian ”Summer of Giacomo” by Alessandro Comodin and best short to Spanish David Munoz for ”Another Night on Earth”.

In the national competition “Centaur” for the best full length documentary film goes to ”Born in the USSR: 28Up” (Part 1) by director Sergey Miroshnichenko, for the best short documentary Valery Shevchenko was awarded for ”Inside a Square Circle”.

The Russian film critics prize as well as the Pavel Kogan Prize was given to Antoine Cattin and Pavel Kostomarov for ”Playback”

http://message2man.com/eng/

St. Petersburg Syndrome

The famous Stendhal syndrome is normally (due to the French author, of course) connected to Florence. For me it happened (again) in St. Petersburg. Several days of intensive driving around in the city with the consequent beauty bombardement of the eyes (the architecture, the open space, the canals etc.) on the islands, along the embarkments, on Kronstadt, in the museums, made me ask the one and only to help me sit down in the airport just before departure. The symptom: dizziness.

Oh, to visit the Russian Museum and discover Ilya Mashkov and Valentin Serov (painting: Children, 1899) in addition to the well known Malevich and Repin – and do go to the two year old museum Erarta on Vasilyevsky Island, the biggest non-governmental museum with contemporary Russian art. A very pleasant museum it is, wonderful work it has, take a look at the work of Elena Figurina’s children motives, just one artist to study, link below.

Poetic images as the ones Tarkovski talks about or as Kossakovsky gives us in his Vivan las Antipodas.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stendhal_syndrome

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilya_Mashkov

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valentin_Serov

http://www.erarta.com/eng/about/

http://artist84.erarta.com/eng/

Collective Work: Winter, Go Away

This is how the film was described at its international premiere in Locarno a couple of months ago: “Ten director graduates from Marina Razbezhkina’s School of Documentary Film and Documentary Theatre lived with a camera for two months in order to chronicle the last “Russian winter” and its popular uprising against Vladimir Putin’s presidential run. People, faces, conversations, protests, failures and triumphs come together to chronicle the campaign.”

And as such one can only state that the students have graduated with bravour. What they give the viewer is a tense insight to all the activities run by the opposition against the fraud comedy around the re-election of Putin in March this year. Most of it happens in the streets, the demonstrations, the slogans, the confrontations with the police, the brutality – but when inside you also, as an example, experience a mother asking her son, who is about to make stilts for a street happening: Would you like to have a cup of tea before saving Russia?! Yes, there is a lot of fun in the film, there has to be as everyone knows that the result of the election was decided in beforehand, there is a lot of freshness, you get the Leacock “feeling of being there”, you get an interview with members of Pussy Riot and footage from the performance in the cathedral, and on the election day you witness what is quite evident a manipulation of votes. Only a few times I felt that I should know more to understand what I see, mostly with who-is-who matters, otherwise I left the film breathless because of tension that had been documented and informed from an anti-Putin point of view – with some fine scenes where Putin supporters discuss with the opposition activists.

Russia, 2012, 90 mins. / Directors: Aleksey Zhiryakov, Denis Klebleev, Dmitriy Kubasov, Askold Kurov, Nadezhda Leontieva, Anna Moiseenko, Madina Mustafina, Zosya Rodkevich, Anton Seregin, Elena Khoreva

Seen at Message to Man Festival, St. Petersburg 2012

http://www.pardolive.ch/catalogue/film.html?fid=629902

Sergey Miroshnichenko: Born in the USSR: 28 Up 1-2

Based on the original idea of Michael Apted – the 7UP series – Sergey Miroshnichenko has filmed a group of Russian kids when they were 7, 14, 21 and now 28 years old. The two-part series (each of them around 100 mins. long) presented at the Message to Man festival in St. Petersburg is an impressive piece of work that you just take in piece by piece = person by person, amazed to experience how much history has played a role in their lives, that started when USSR existed and took a completely different direction when the empire fell apart.

As in the work of Michael Apted (who now films kids who are in the 50’es!) Miroshnichenko cuts back and forward in time to let us see the 7 year old innocent having hopes for the future, the 14 year old having discovered more of the world including the opposite sex, the 21 year old who has already had the first child, and changed work several times and the 28 year old who divorced or has moved to another country – and did, in most cases, not have their child hopes fulfilled. There is drama, there is sadness but also happiness, and there are critical comments to Russian politics or religious commitments or… yes, they are like you and me, but their lives have definitely been destined by the outer circumstances. Like the Georgians, like the Lithuanians who lived in the same country when they were born but in independent republics when they were 7.

However, what comes out strongest in the films – where the director goes from person to person, with in-between-montage sequences that have a group of them comment on the same theme – is the emotions conveyed to us like (first part) the small boy Andrey, who when 7 do not have his parents, who get adopted to one family abroad and then to another one in the US, a boy marked by his past, and a young man who sits down as a 28 year old saying that he does not want to be filmed any longer. For personal reasons that he does not talk about. Heartbreaking as many of the stories are at the same time as you are impressed by the reflections that they make as kids or as grown-ups. Or (second part) the twins from St. Petersburg with their gamin faces constantly in trouble in opposition to each other, desparate to have a good life but not achieving a lot of what they hoped for. Fun and sad at the same time.

It is difficult to make a film with so many characters but Miroshnichenko succeeds to have the narrative go in a smooth rythm, and in a warm tone, with fine associative ”bridges” and with a voice-over that glues it together when necessary. You learn so much about Russia, well about life watching this work.  

http://message2man.com/eng/program_english/id/2/block/17

Mika Ronkainen: Finnish Blood, Swedish Heart

This morning, my daily newspaper reminded me of a John Cage-quote: “I like to be moved, but I don’t like to be pushed”. Two days ago in Oulu, Finland, I found myself in a situation which I liked. It might have been some of the vodka from the night before, but during the end credits of this film my eyes couldn’t resist the welling of moist any more. Am I that big a cry-baby? Well, I know I wasn’t the only one in the theatre feeling this way and the film just slowly took a gentle grip of my throat and never let go.

Kai is a Finnish musician who – after he got a son – realizes that he in a strange way misses a sense of belonging, probably because he spent most of his childhood in Sweden. The film consists for a large part of him and his father going on a road trip to Gothenburg trying to understand that period. Kai and his father have never spoken much of the moving back and forth between countries, thus giving Kai a sense of rootlessness. Now they gradually start to talk – and on the way they are also meeting other Finnish Swedes under various circumstances which weaves into the story and theme.

The other main part of the film is even more congenially intertwined. It consists of live recordings of songs written by Finnish Swedes in the past and now performed by a new generation on the very locations Kai and his father reaches on their trip. It sounds corny, and it probably is, but it works so well and the music and the lyrics are poetically commenting on the theme of not quite belonging or even being looked down on as a foreigner in a foreign country.

Three cameras followed the pair on the trip and the cinematic skills – the filming, the editing and the sound mix – are just as they should be. Okay, maybe there is a few times where you suspect the director has asked those taking part in the film to say specific things or that they themselves were self-conscious about bringing information to the audience. And maybe you see one or two birds too many (the trick the film uses to tell us that Kai is thinking of his own ornithology interested son), but I can forgive that because Kai’s and his father’s relationship is depicted so empathically with lots of sweet moments, music, dialogue and pauses.

It didn’t win anything at Nordisk Panorama and has been rejected at both CPH:DOX and IDFA which either proofs that festival juries and selecting committees are insensitive bastards or that I really am a wuss. Okay, it may not be cutting edge or a glimpse into the future of documentary film making, but it really should be a globally appealing film. I feel very rooted in my Danish soil and I don’t have kids, but still I will have to give it at full six pens – simply because it made such a profound impression by moving me and not pushing me.

Mika Ronkainen: Finnish Blood, Swedish Heart, Finland 2012, 90 min. Seen at Nordisk Panorama in Oulu, Finland.

PS:

I made a quite grave mistake above in the review: Sweden finns and Finnish swedes are two completely different things

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish-speaking_population_of_Finland/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweden_Finns/  

Kai and father don’t meet Finnish swedes in Sweden cos Finnish swedes live in Finland. They meet Sweden finns.

Poesi, eneste gyldige metode

Han er jo fordingsfuld og uforsonlig den Tarkovskij. Til FILMKLUB FOF’s møde i aftes, hvor vi diskuterede Ada Bligaard Søbys film, havde jeg taget et lille stykke med, som jeg havde oversat (lidt frit) fra Andrej Tarkovskijs bog Die versiegelte Zeit, hvor han stiller den poetiske film op over for den kommercielle filmproduktion: “… Når der tales om filmiske retninger, om forskellige slags film, så handler det som regel om den kommercielle filmproduktion, det handler om komedier, westerns, psykologiske dramaer, krimier, musicals, horror, katastrofefilm osv. Det drejer sig om massemedier, forbrugsvarer, konsum om man vil. Filmkunsten bliver imidlertid desværre påtvunget disse allestedsnærværende former udefra, af kommercielle interesser. ” Men filmen, cinematografien, som det hed tidligere, konkluderer han, “… kender i sit egentlige væsen kun en eneste form for tænken – det er den poetiske, som forener det ’uforenbare’ (jeg har ikke lyst til at oversætte ved ’modsætningerne’…) og paradokserne, den poetiske tænken, som gør filmkunst til en adækvat udtryksform for sin autors tanke og følelse…

Måske kan det også fungere som en kommentar til Tue Steen Müllers dybt foruroligende overvejelser nedenfor?

James Marsh: Project Nim

I guess that most readers know that James Marsh ”Project Nim” is about the dramatic life of a chimpanse… nevertheless read how Peter Bradshaw precisely introduced the film in Guardian August 11 2011:

Project Nim was a sensational Pygmalion-type experiment devised by Professor Herb Terrace, a specialist in primate cognitive abilities at New York’s Columbia University. In 1973, he wanted to see if a chimp (called Nim) could be taken into a human family and taught to communicate with sign language. Yet Marsh elegantly shows his audience that this is not entirely what Project Nim was about. Without any of the human participants acknowledging or even realising it, Project Nim was effectively a manipulative experiment in human sexual behaviour and family life.

Terrace was evidently a charismatic and powerful alpha-gorilla academic who simply declared that a former student of his (with whom he once had a sexual relationship) would have the honour of mothering his chimp-pupil…”

I can only support this analysis of this good film and add that it clearly demonstrates Marsh skills in building, one could say designing a story so it functions dramaturgically. He separates stylistically the interviews from the fantastic archive material with Nim, he has a strong music side the whole way through, as well as a sound design, and there are graphics (mostly words of or drawings from Nim’s sign language) filling the screen once in a while. It is all very effectively conveyed, we are asked to laugh and to cry at the right moments, it is a superb construction like “Man on Wire” was it, like “Searching for Sugarman” (same producer) is it. The use of effects to reach the goal is not hidden for the spectator, on the contrary. What I am trying to say, is that I felt like looking at a form that prevented me from entering the film totally, even if I wanted to. There are other new documentaries which are copying the style of Marsh or are a bit alike (Erroll Morris is a master of designed documentaries), am I the only one who is afraid that this trend will end up in predictable, designed superficiality?  

Seen at Message to Man, St. Petersburg 2012

http://www.project-nim.com/

UK/USA, 2011, 93 mins.

Nordisk Panorama 2012

Awards were distributed at the Nordisk Panorama festival in Oulu. The best documentary prize went to the succesful Danish documentary “Ballroom Dancer” by Andreas Kofoed & Christian Bonke. The jury motivation:

“The Nordic Documentary Award goes to a perfect example of the power of documentary to capture the fragility and intensity of human emotion in a world that demands perfection and excellence at any cost. With cinematic grace and passion, the film presents dance as a beautifully realized microcosm of the complexities of human intimacy. Ultimately this is a film about love.”

http://filmkontakt.com/

Kossakovsky on “Why Poverty”

Viktor Kossakovsky was on his way home from Vilnius Documentary Festival, where he presented a retrospective of his films from “Belovs” to “Vivan las Antipodas”. I was on my way to the 22nd edition of St. Petersburg festival “Message to Man”. While waiting for boarding permission, the director invited me to watch his newest work, “Lullaby”, a short film (around 3 mins.), he had made for the big documentary series initiative “Why Poverty”. Shot in Berlin with a focus on a Deutsche Bank door leading to cash withdrawal machines, the director has made an original contribution to the short film section of the series. It should be watchable very soon according to the site of “Why Poverty”, read this text clip:  

”Why Poverty? uses film to get people talking about poverty.

We’ve commissioned award-winning film makers to make eight documentaries about poverty, and new and emerging talents to make around 30 short films. The films tackle big issues and pose difficult questions, but they’re also moving, subtle and thought-provoking stories.

They transmit around the world in November 2012, on 62 national broadcasters reaching 500 million people. They’ll be accompanied by events designed to spark global and national debates and an online campaign to get people asking “Why Poverty?”

You can watch clips and shorts online now, and find out more about what’s happening in your country.

After November, the documentaries will be available to everyone online and we’ll begin an outreach programme, building on the momentum from broadcast…”

Photo: Kossakovsky in Vilnius.

http://whypoverty.net/

Crossroads Film Workshop Cairo

No, I did not see the pyramids or the Egyptian Museum. Yes, I saw the Nile from my hotel and had a quiet wonderful boat trip late night on the river. Yes, I crossed the Tahrir Square every morning on the way to the venue of the workshop, I attended as a tutor. And I saw how the street entrance to the American Embassy was blocked with huge stones. But on the tuesday morning where the workshop started, everything had calmed down after days of riots due to the film, everyone talks about but few have seen, including me.

So there was little, actually no time for seeing the sights but time dedicated to see filmmakers with documentary projects under the umbrella of the Crossroads film programme initiated and run by AFAC (The Arab Fund for Arts & Culture). A film programme so much needed – as the manager of the programme, Rima Mismar, wrote to me in the invitation letter, ”launched a year ago to support emerging filmmakers from the Arab world working on projects related to “possibility” and “change”… for young filmmakers who represent an exceptional talent cross-section from our region”.

As one who has followed the changes in the Arab world during the last year(s) this initiative is to be so much welcomed after news clips, and reportages, and the many documentaries, many of them good it has to be said, made by non-Arab filmmakers.

Back to Cairo and the workshop where you as a tutor arrive having read the projects, knowing a couple of them in beforehand, curious to meet the makers, talk to them, see material, see previous work – to try to have an impression that can form the basis for feedback the filmmakers can profit from. Of course it goes both ways, the filmmakers should know who you are. It always helps to talk about something that has nothing to do with the film to be done.

It was at the Cinematheque the workshop took place. Situated in an old, pretty worn, decadently beautiful art nouveau building, 8 floors, a charming hotel on the top floor, and, if I got it right, the plan is to have three floors dedicated to

film – the Cinematheque, production companies, facilities etc.

First meeting – with Mohamed Rashad, from Alexandris, whose first long documentary project “The Little Eagles” is a fascinating generation story built primarily on the relationship between the director and his father, an orderly and ordinary Egyptian worker, who was never politically active but an always very well informed citizen, taking care of family and work. Who is now worried about his son, who – contrary to his friends whose parents were “little eagles”, politically active in the 70’es – got involved in the revolutionary activities in the Tahrir. By chance because “revolution. I am not sure why. Maybe because the word is alien to me. I am not used to it. It was never in my vocabulary. I do not know who called it, a revolution. Maybe it’s one of those I want to make a film about. It’s one of the words they were brought up to appreciate. They (the friends, ed.) were raised to read books about revolutions, communism, socialism, “Karl Marx”, “Maxim Gorky”, “Sheikh Imam’s songs”, “Ahmed Fouad Negm’s poetry.”

Apart from having an impressive knowledge of high-class Danish ceramics design (!), especially Søholm, from the island of Bornholm, Lebanese freelance photo reporter and cameraman, cultural project coordinator AND film director Fadi Yeni Turk talked me into understanding that his “Monumentum” was not, as I wrongly suggested at the beginning, of our meeting, until I saw previous work clips, a three part series about monuments and their history in squares in Beirut, Bagdad and Manama in Bahrein. What he offers is an original, intelligent, essayistic documentary: “

“Within a very special context for the Arab world these days, where the Monument is still to be destroyed, adapted or reconstructed and has yet to become common heritage, “Monumentum” wants to bet that these social, historical and political issues can be representable, should be even represented beyond their abstraction and complexity; the film goes beyond the apparent paradox of wanting to seize through cinema, an art of movement “par excellence”, what specifically seeks to lay, immobilize, simplify history: the public monument.” Photo: The Victory Arch in Baghdad erected by Saddam Hussein.

I had met with Sara Ishaq before (at the Edinburgh Pitch) and can only repeat my admiration and high expectations to this film, that in the following months will be at the editing phase. I have seen wonderful material from a story that has a universal appeal with its focus on three generations. The best I can do is to quote the exposé of the young filmmaker:

“After four years of complete disconnection from my Yemeni roots and tentative family ties, I travel back to Yemen. The story follows my endeavour to craft a single identity for myself between my dual Yemeni and Scottish backgrounds. Little did I know, however, that Yemen itself was grappling with its own identity crisis and struggle for freedom. The film is a personal story, which begins as a reunion between estranged family members and develops into an all-engulfing popular uprising. It focuses on the shifting dynamics between women and men within the context of a modern Yemeni family, testing all preconceived ideas about identity, social customs, familial and social bonds as women’s roles and input become increasingly integral to the Yemeni revolution.” Title “Father Land”.

In workshops like this projects are at different stages of development. Egyptian Mohammad Shawky Hassan was in New York during the revolution, listened to the radio news and wants to make a film that (maybe, I am still thinking about how, he told me) “is made up of 10 to 15 panoramic shots of empty indoor and outdoor spaces in New York City and one in Cairo, with the character “A” framed in each almost motionless, carrying out a basic physical activity. Each shot will be a 360-degree slow extreme wide pan revealing details of the filmed space. The Arabic soundtrack is placed over the images, with English subtitles.” I saw two of the director’s previous films, we talkes about Jørgen Leth and Roy Anderson, and I have no doubt that we will see an interesting, creative and playful film from his hands.

The same goes for – yes, I am very positive to all the projects, carefully selected by the people at AFAC – Bahïa Bencheik El Fegoun, Algerian director with a producer, also Algerian, who has an office in Paris. Her film project, named “Algerians, State of Affairs, State of Mind…”, is intriguing, not only because we hear so little from the country, but also because the director in her writing shows original narrative visions from this personal starting point:

Sometimes, it takes a special occasion for an individual and a word to truly meet. What I mean by this is that one encounters a lot of words in a lifetime, but some words we understand at first glance and some others we never really understand despite our lifelong interaction with them.” This paragraph beautifully and accurately expresses the situation in which we, the word revolution and I, are today; our encounter, our true encounter, will take place in this movie.”

For a year the director has – day by day – gathered notes and news, written or visual – on what happened in the country in terms of riots, demonstrations and other means of opposition. She wants to use that as the backbone of the film introducing three revolutionary, non-violent characters of great charisma.

Also Jasmina Metwaly and Philip Rick – Polish/Egyptian and German/Egyptian – has clearly had their project chosen due to their original ambition, read their intro text:

“Workers are in need of their body, they need it to work, they need their working spaces (exterior bodies) to exist, but they can’t do it without their dignity. Workers need their voice to be heard, not only as a collective roar, but individually. This is a film about workers. Throughout the ongoing Egyptian Revolution some workers have lost a relative or friend, most continue to be exploited by factory owners and many are fighting back and resisting. This film mixes the forms of documentary and fiction in order to see the Egyptian revolution from workers’ perspective beyond the factory’s heavy gates, beyond the frozen assembly lines and rusty machinery. We want to challenge both the visual discourse of the role of workers in film, as well as the political narrative of whom this revolution is made up of in Egypt.”

Brechtian theatre director and script writer Hanaa Abdel Fattah will take part in the (filmic) dramatization of the filmic documentation the two directors intend to do, Mostafa Youssef is the producer with his newly founded company Seen Films, based in Cairo. The company is also part of the production of “Father Land”, see above.

The seventh filmmaker I met is from Syria. He/she showed strong material from a very personal point of view. No more do I wish to write about the film project, the actual situation in the country taken into consideration.

AFAC intends to follow the filmmakers during the process of development/production/distribution, first finished films to be waited during 2013, two fiction films are also on the list – AFAC gives the full package, Bravo!

Apart from the Crossroads Programme AFAC has for years run a Documentary Programme, this text is taken from the website of the Fund: The Arab Documentary Film Program (ADFP), a partnership with the Sundance Institute, aims to be a launch pad for documentary filmmakers, providing them with the financial and professional resources to create influential work that is globally recognized. During each cycle of the ADFP, around 15 feature-length documentary projects in the script/development (up to US$15,000 per project) and production/post-production (up to US$50,000 per project) stages are awarded grants worth up to $500,000. In addition to providing direct funding, Sundance and AFAC cooperate with renowned international festivals or institutions to bring together grantees with experts and industry professionals to provide tailored support, consultation and networking opportunities.

www.arabculturefund.org